Search
Close this search box.
Old man with horse

Equine Therapy vs. Traditional Therapy: Choosing The Right Path For Healing

Share this post:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn

When choosing the right path for healing, many individuals feel overwhelmed by the options before them. 

Two particularly distinct routes are equine therapy and traditional therapy. 

Both have unique benefits and can significantly impact someone’s journey towards better mental health. 

What is Equine Therapy?

Equine Therapy, also known as horse therapy, involves interactions between patients and horses. 

It’s conducted under the guidance of a professional therapist, often in an outdoor setting. 

Activities can range from grooming, feeding, and leading a horse to riding. 

These interactions can help individuals develop non-verbal communication, assertiveness, problem-solving, and confidence.

Patients who engage in equine therapy often report a significant reduction in stress, anxiety, and depression. 

The therapy is based on the concept that horses mirror humans’ emotions, providing immediate feedback to help individuals understand and process their feelings. 

It’s particularly noted for its success with individuals who haven’t responded well to more traditional forms of therapy.

The Benefits of Equine Therapy

Emotional Growth and Learning

Horses are sensitive creatures capable of mirroring the emotions and moods of the humans around them. 

This reflective quality can help individuals become more aware of their feelings and behaviors. 

It’s a hands-on approach to developing a deeper understanding of oneself and improving emotional intelligence.

Stress Reduction 

Spending time with animals, particularly in a natural, outdoor setting, can significantly decrease stress and anxiety. 

The simple acts of petting, grooming, or even being near a horse can have a calming effect, reducing blood pressure and heart rate.

Improves Communication Skills

Equine therapy requires a different form of communication–more about action and emotion than words. 

This can be especially beneficial for those who struggle with traditional verbal communication, helping them express themselves in new, more effective ways.

Boosts Confidence and Self-Efficacy

Learning to control and interact with such a large animal can empower individuals, boosting their self-confidence. 

Achieving tasks and building a relationship with the horse can enhance feelings of self-efficacy and independence.

Encourages Responsibility

Caring for a horse’s needs can foster a sense of responsibility and attentiveness in individuals. 

This aspect of equine therapy helps teach participants about the importance of caring for another living being, which can be extrapolated to personal lives and relationships.

Enhances Social Skills

Equine therapy is often conducted in group settings, which encourages interaction with others who are facing similar challenges. 

This can improve social skills, promote empathy, and facilitate the formation of supportive social networks.

Physical Benefits

Besides the emotional and psychological advantages, equine therapy offers physical benefits. 

Riding, leading, and grooming can improve balance, coordination, and physical strength.

Other Things to Consider Before Getting an Equine Therapy

woman holding horse rope

While the benefits of equine therapy are compelling, there are other considerations to consider when exploring this therapeutic option.

Accessibility

Access to equine therapy is less widespread than traditional therapy models due to the need for specific facilities and trained horses. 

It’s important to research and find reputable programs within a manageable distance.

Cost

Equine therapy can be more expensive than other forms of therapy due to the costs associated with maintaining horses and facilities. 

Some insurance plans may not cover this form of therapy, so it’s crucial to look into financial options, such as scholarships, sliding-scale fees, or nonprofit programs.

Allergies or Fear of Animals

Individuals with allergies to animals or those who fear horses may not find this therapy form suitable or comfortable. 

When exploring equine therapy, it’s essential to consider personal comfort levels and physical health.

Commitment 

Commitment and openness to the process are key to progress, like any therapy. 

Equine therapy requires a willingness to engage with the horse and to consider what the interactions reveal about the individual’s emotions and behaviors.

Preparation

As many equine therapy sessions occur outside, participants might need to prepare for outdoor conditions. 

This means dressing appropriately for the weather and being ready to interact with nature.

What is Traditional Therapy?

Traditional therapy, on the other hand, encompasses a range of treatments, including cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), psychotherapy, and counseling. 

These therapies primarily involve verbal communication and are conducted in a more clinical setting, such as a therapist’s office. 

Traditional therapy aims to explore the patient’s thoughts, feelings, and behaviors to develop strategies for overcoming various mental health issues.

This form of therapy has been well-researched and is considered highly effective for a wide range of psychological disorders, including anxiety, depression, and PTSD. 

It offers a structured environment where individuals can safely explore their issues with a trained professional guiding them through the process.

The Benefits of Traditional Therapy

Evidence-Based Care

One of the most significant benefits of traditional therapy is its strong grounding in decades of research. 

Approaches like CBT are well-documented for their effectiveness in treating a variety of mental health conditions, including anxiety and depression.

Structured Support

Sessions typically follow a structure that provides stability and regularity, essential for many people seeking mental health support. 

Knowing what to expect can lower anxiety about the process and help individuals prepare for sessions.

Develops Self-Awareness

By deep diving into personal experiences, traditional therapy helps individuals gain insights into their thinking patterns and behavior that may keep them stuck or unhappy.

Improves Coping Skills

Therapists work to equip individuals with practical tools and strategies for managing stress, anxiety, and other challenging emotions or situations.

Enhances Communication Skills

Focusing on talking through problems, therapy naturally bolsters one’s ability to articulate thoughts and emotions, which can benefit personal and professional relationships.

Offers a Safe Space

Traditional therapy provides a confidential and non-judgmental environment where individuals can openly share their experiences and thoughts without fear of repercussion or criticism.

Facilitates Healing Relationships

The therapeutic relationship between the client and therapist is a cornerstone of traditional therapy. 

This bond can model healthy interactions and offer the client a reparative emotional experience.

Addresses a Wide Range of Issues

From everyday stress to more severe psychological conditions, there’s a traditional therapy form that can be tailored to meet a person’s specific needs.

Promotes Long-Term Well-being

Many find that traditional therapy’s benefits extend beyond the immediate issues, leading to long-term improvements in mental wellness and life satisfaction.

Flexibility in Delivery

Sessions can be conducted face-to-face, over the phone, or via video, accommodating different preferences and lifestyles.

Other Things to Consider Before Getting a Traditional Therapy

Kissing horse

Although traditional therapy offers numerous advantages, it’s crucial to contemplate a few points before taking this path.

Finding the Right Therapist

The effectiveness of therapy often hinges on the relationship with the therapist. 

Finding someone you connect with is important, which might mean meeting with a few therapists before finding the right fit.

Time Commitment

Sessions typically last around an hour and are most beneficial when attended regularly, such as weekly. Making time for therapy in busy schedules is an important consideration.

Financial Investment

The cost of therapy can be a barrier for some. 

While insurance may cover parts of the expense, there are often deductibles and copays to consider. 

Sliding scale fees or community clinics can be alternatives for those with financial limitations.

Emotional Work

Engaging in traditional therapy can be mentally and emotionally challenging. 

It often requires facing difficult thoughts and memories, which can sometimes feel uncomfortable.

Stigma

Unfortunately, there’s still some stigma around seeking mental health treatment. 

It’s essential to prioritize one’s well-being and remember that seeking help is a sign of strength, not weakness.

Accessibility

Living in remote areas or having certain disabilities can make accessing in-person therapy more challenging. 

However, the rise of teletherapy is helping to address these accessibility issues.

Choosing the Right Therapy for You

Man and woman with a horse

When deciding between equine therapy and traditional therapy, consider the following:

Personal Comfort

Do you feel more at ease in nature and around animals or do you prefer a more conventional setting? Your comfort level plays a vital role in the effectiveness of the therapy.

Type of Healing Needed

Reflect on whether your needs align with expressive and experiential healing from interacting with horses or traditional therapy’s introspective and dialogue-based healing.

Accessibility and Commitment

Consider how far you’re willing to travel and how much time you can commit regularly. 

Equine therapy might require more travel and potentially a more significant time commitment.

Financial Considerations

Evaluate your financial situation and insurance coverage to see which option is financially viable for the long term.

Trial and Error

Remember, choosing a therapy type isn’t always a black-and-white decision. 

It might take trying both to see which resonates more with your personality and therapeutic goals.

Final Thoughts

Both equine therapy and traditional therapy offer profound benefits for mental wellness, though they take very different paths to get there. 

Whether you’re drawn to intuitive and active engagement with horses or the reflective and conversational depth of traditional therapy, the most important thing is to choose a path that feels right for you. 

It’s your journey toward healing, growth, and self-discovery; the right therapy can be a powerful ally.

Remember, mental health care is deeply personal, and what works for one person might not work for another. 

It’s all about finding the approach that makes you feel supported, understood, and empowered to face life’s challenges. 

Whatever you choose, taking the step to seek therapy is a commendable act of bravery and self-care.

At Equine Guidance, we offer a unique and transformative experience leveraging the healing power of horses. 

Our specialized sessions facilitate a deep connection with these compassionate creatures, guiding you toward self-discovery and renewed resilience. 

Visit Equine Guidance to discover more about our services or to schedule a session. 

We’re here to help you start on a journey of healing and self-mastery in the scenic Sedona Verde Valley. 

Contact us today and be ready to experience transformative healing.

On Key

Related Posts

3 white horse

The Comprehensive Benefits of Equine Therapy

Horse therapy (Equine-Assisted Therapy (EAT) involves interactions between patients and horses.  Healthcare professionals use it to promote physical and emotional growth in people facing everything

Retirement

Equine Therapy for Veterans with PTSD

The journey back to civilian life for veterans can be fraught with numerous challenges, particularly for those grappling with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).  Traumas from